Talk:Battle of Warsaw 1920

Several questions

Model 17 Stielhandgranate

Are you sure that it is Model 17? It seems to me that this is Model 24, as in every other movie with German grenades. I doubt that a real Model 17 could survive until 2011.

A Model 17 doesn't need to survive. It's very easy to make custom props.Chitoryu12 00:51, 14 May 2012 (CDT)

Of course. But I doubt that any movie maker would make such props when there are plenty dummy Model 24s. And the grenade on the screenshot looks more like Model 24. But I don't insist if you are completely sure that this is Model 17. Greg-Z 02:20, 14 May 2012 (CDT)

One more MG

I have found in Internet a screenshot from the movie:

Error creating thumbnail: File missing

This light MG is most likely based on Czech Vz. 59 which is disguised as MG08/15.

I think that it is definitely a Czech Vz. 59. Also if there are no objections as I mentioned earlier I have been trying to clear up the spelling and grammar on the page and will continue to do so. --6pulkpancerna 18:51, 13 May 2012 (CDT)

BA-27

The armored car which is "playing the role" of Soviet BA-27 (which, in turn, didn't exist in 1920) is a modern replica of Polish Vz.34.

I am just trying to fix a lot of the spelling mistakes on this page.

- Greg-Z 14:44, 13 May 2012 (CDT)

Thx for all repair. Also, it may be Model15 [1]. But certainly not the Model 24 - it is obvious anachronism. Oh, and how it is with the Browning Hi-Power in 1920? :))) :)))--Pandolfini 16:14, 13 May 2012 (CDT)

We can see a lot of anachronisms in movies, including this one. So I think that the grenade on screen is Model 24 which is impersonating Model 15 or Model 17. Also look at other movies about WW I: you'll see there Model 24s also. Greg-Z 22:24, 13 May 2012 (CDT)

Yes, O. K. But aim is perhaps to inform the viewer what weapons the his heroes to used in historical reality. I write about it here - All Quiet on the Western Front (1979)--Pandolfini 00:28, 14 May 2012 (CDT)

I cannot agree. If we see Browning Hi-Power in 1920 we say that this is anachronistically used Hi-Power and don't say that this is a Model 1903, right? So if a Model 24 grenade is used, we say that a Model 24 is used in the movie though it stands for Model 17. I think so. Greg-Z 02:20, 14 May 2012 (CDT)

In the Browning Hi-Power to see at a glance, so I can blame. Otherwise, the presumption of innocence applies everywhere, right? Accuse the filmmakers of anachronism by blurred shot? It was there that I can write it straight, it's not a grenade, but the sand full dummy :)--Pandolfini 02:52, 14 May 2012 (CDT)

Unidentified MG

Error creating thumbnail: File missing

It will help someone identify what kind of light machine gun?