Marston is seen loading(unloading?) a New Army revolver. The colt new service was actually first made in 1899, it was adopted by the US Armed Forces in 1909. In all honesty though
this revolver could be either one. Sure! I wait the may 18th for the definitive answer. It is named the 'Double Action Revolver' In-game
I change my answer to a Colt Police Positive. I saw it listed on an official list of features over on IGN boards. I think that would make most sense since that way the more powerful Peacemaker would still reign supreme as a more powerful handgun. It's the classic video game trade off. Faster firing but less powerful, as opposed to slower firing but more power. Still like the above poster said, we won't know until it's out but I, Cole Thorton, am calling it here and now that it will be a Police Positive.
its a close call but im pretty sure its a new service, take a closer look.
it could be a colt M1899 Revolver in .38 Long Colt
Judging by leaked gameplay footage this will be our first rifle just like Red Dead Revolver.
Despite the fact that the real Spencer is loaded from a tube magazine in the butt-stock, the game depicts the rifle as a seven-round repeating breech-loader. Someone didn't do their homework.
Looks like a Krag-Jørgensen judging by the rear sight.--Pølaris 23:57, 12 May 2010 (UTC)
it is the Krag...you can tell by the magazine door around the bolt
Unknown Revolver
I noticed a nickel finished revolver on one screencap, that could be the Schofield but looks somewhat different:
[1]
Any ideas?
It could be the Colt New Service swing out revolver with a nickel finish
That's just the way the enemy guns look, makes it easier to spot when you go to pick up ammunition. They make the Winchesters look like '66 "Yellow Boys" because of that effect. -Cole Thorton