The Glock 19 is the standard sidearm carried by Detectives in the NYPD including Tony Caruso Jr. (Josh Groban) and Cora Vasquez (Monica Barbaro). Uniformed officers and FBI agents are also seen with Glock 19s.
Tony Jr.'s own Glock is at the center of the first episode "Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01), where it's used to frame him in an incredibly convoluted way for a murder.
The NYPD rangemaster, Chet Finch in "Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01) is seen armed with a nickel Colt Gold Cup National Match when he discovers Tony Jr (Josh Groban) and Cora (Monica Barbaro) investigating the range for evidence.
Error creating thumbnail: File missingColt Gold Cup National Match (Mark IV, Series 80) Enhanced with stainless steel finish and wraparound rubber grips - .45 ACPError creating thumbnail: File missingFinch with his Colt in hand. Note his terrible cup and saucer grip, something rather unfitting of someone who manages a shooting range. "Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01).Error creating thumbnail: File missingBetter side shot of the Colt Gold Cup, here you can clearly see the rear adjustable sights, skeletonized hammer and Colt markings. "Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01).
Kahr K9
Cora Vasquez (Monica Barbaro) carries a Kahr K9 as her personal sidearm in "Who Framed The Good Cop" (S1E01). She nearly empties it and then passes it to Tony Jr, as he uses the last round in the chamber to hit Chet Finch.
The Bunny Mask killer in "What is The Supermodel's Secret" (S1E02) is seen using a two-tone SIG-Sauer P229R with wood grips and a silver suppressor to kill Mr. Monte. The gun is later handled by Belinda Mannix (Emma Ishta) and used against its owner. The gun seems to be missing its rear sight.
In "What is The Supermodel's Secret" (S1E02) Tony Jr. (Josh Groban) is seen drawing a Smith & Wesson M&P9 instead of his usual Glock 19. This must be a continuity error, as it only happens in one scene.
In a continuity error in "Who Killed the Guy on the Ski Lift?" (S1E07), Tony Jr's (Josh Groban) Glock 19 briefly turns into a Smith & Wesson 5904 when he enters a hotel room with other police officers.
Donovan Demark (Dan Byrd) uses one in "Who Cut Mrs. Ackroyd in Half?" (S1E10).
One of the thieves at the restaurant in "Why Kill a Busboy" (S1E09) is armed with a polish P-64 pistol. He then uses it to kill the aforementioned busboy in the restaurant's kitchen. Big Tony (Tony Danza) identifies it as "Makarov automatic" (which would be somewhat correct) and that it ejects to the left, prompting Cora to look in a different place and find the spent casing used in the murder. The latter comment about the P-64 is incorrect, unless either Tony got the direction of the shooter wrong (which is possible, since the kitchen's doors were closed) or the shooter shot the gun upside down, which is a very unusual thing to do.
Very few handguns eject to the left (the Walther P5 being an example) and the polish P-64 is not one of them.
An assassin in "Will the Good Cop Bowl 300?" (S1E04) is seen using Joey's Smith & Wesson Model 36 against him after a confrontation gone wrong at the bowling alley. When talking about the slug recovered in the victim's head, Cora refers to it as a 9mm, which is incorrect as the revolver is chambered in .38 Special.
What appears to be a Colt Carbine variant is seen held by some police officers in "Who Is the Ugly German Lady?" (S1E03). Though only seen briefly and out of focus, the shape is mostly recognizable.
