User talk:Gunner5

Bioshock

I don't know why you keep changing the page to claim the Thompson in Bioshock was an M1A1, but it isn't even slightly accurate. The player-used gun in the game has a vertical front grip, a drum magazine and a poorly-rendered cutts compensator; the M1A1 has none of these. Evil Tim 10:55, 7 September 2011 (CDT)

It has a triangular sight, like the M1A1, it has a bolt on the side, like an M1A1, It has an M1A1 stock, M1A1s can also take vertical grips as well, ladies and gentelmen, i think this gun is based off of the M1A1 thompson.What cutts compensator are you talking about? --Gunner5

Then you're wrong. An M1A1 cannot take a drum mag, does not have a cutts compensator, and does not have a front grip. The Cutts is the thing at the front of the barrel; it's poorly realised on the Bioshock gun with no openings and the front sight is at the wrong end of it. The "wings" protecting the sight on the Bioshock gun are the wrong shape for either version, as is the stock, so that hardly proves anything in either direction. About the only thing on it that is certainly not right for an M1921 is the charging handle location. Evil Tim 11:08, 7 September 2011 (CDT)

An M1A1 can have a cutts compensator,and can have a vertical grip, it cant take a drum mag, but Call of Duty World at War depicted it, why can't Bioshock? Excuse my poor grammar, im not feeling well today.--Gunner5

The one pictured on that page rather obviously isn't mounting it's original barrel (it also has cooling fins, which the M1A1 barrel doesn't have either). The one in World at War is best described as a rebarreled M1A1 because it has all the other features of an M1A1 correctly depicted; on the other hand, the one in Bioshock has only one feature from an M1A1 shown correctly (the charging handle) while it has an older front grip, barrel, compensator, and magazine. These features add up to mean it should be labelled as an older model with a few inaccuracies and one feature from the wrong version, not a ridiculously modified M1A1. Evil Tim 11:20, 7 September 2011 (CDT)

Fine, are you the one who readded the picture on the Kelly's Heroes page?