Mr. White (Harvey Keitel), Mr. Orange (Tim Roth), Mr. Pink (Steve Buscemi), and Mr. Blonde (Michael Madsen) were all armed with one Smith & Wesson 659 9mm pistol. They are distinguished from M1911s and other Smith & Wesson variants by their second generation features, stainless steel construction, and double stack frames.
Though all of the thieves guns look to be the same, Mr. Orange's (Tim Roth) Smith & Wesson 659 has a round trigger guard and a black magazine, further alluding to the fact that he is not like the rest of the thieves.
Though everyone is given a Smith & Wesson Model 659 for the robbery, Mr. White (Harvey Keitel) is seen using a Smith & Wesson 639 with Pachmayr grips. We can assume, being that he is a professional thief, that this is his personal gun, and not a continuity error in the film. During the getaway, he is seen dual wielding his personal Smith & Wesson 639 with his issued Smith & Wesson 659, further strengthening this theory. In the special edition DVD, on the second disk a deleted scene can be found which briefly shows Mr White's/Larry Dimmick's police record. This informs us that his weapon of choice is a Smith and Wesson 9mm, even further strengthening the personal 639 theory.
Error creating thumbnail: File missingSmith & Wesson Model 639 with Pachmayr grips 9x19mm. This is the Screen used 639 carried and fired by Harvey Keitel in the film.
Mr. Orange packs 2 handguns while getting ready to meet Nice Guy Eddie (Chris Penn) Mr. White, and Mr. Pink for a meeting with Joe Cabot (Lawrence Tierney). The automatic he holsters at his ankle is a Beretta 950 Jetfire in .25 ACP.
Mr. Orange's second gun is a Charter Arms Off Duty with Pachmayr grips. He checks to make sure the cylinder is loaded, swings the cylinder back in, and then places it in his coat pocket. Mr. Orange is also seen with this gun in a paddle holster in an earlier scene, so it is safe to assume that this is his police issued sidearm.
Error creating thumbnail: File missingCharter Arms Off Duty with Pachmayr Grips .38 SpecialFile:RD-CAOD-1.jpgMr. Orange's holstered Charter Arms Off Duty, circled in red, as he talks to Officer Holdaway.Error creating thumbnail: File missingMr. Orange goes to load his Beretta Jetfire, next to his Charter Arms Off Duty revolver.Error creating thumbnail: File missingMr. Orange checks the cylinder of his Charter Arms Off Duty.File:RD-CAOD-4.jpgIn a deleted scene, Mr. Orange looks through mugshots trying to find out Mr. White's identity. He calls Officer Holdaway, tells him the information, and then takes his Charter Arms Off Duty and dry fires it at Mr. White's mugshot.
Colt Detective Special
After Mr. White kills the pursuing cops with his two pistols, he and Mr. Orange walk until they find a car driving by. They aim their guns at the driver, a woman, and attempt to take it. She produces a pre-1972 nickel plated Colt Detective Special from her glove compartment and shoots Mr. Orange in the stomach as he opens the door to pull her out of the car. Another nickel Detective Special is "Mexican carried" by Joe (Lawrence Tierney), distinguished as a Detective Special by it's round edged butt. It is likely that the same gun was used in both scenes.
In the final standoff between Eddie, Joe Cabot, and Mr. White, Eddie aims his Smith & Wesson Model 66 Snub Nose at Mr. White, threatening to kill him if he doesn't take his gun off of Joe. Eddie also uses this gun to shoot Officer Nash.
A Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputy is seen with a Colt Trooper in his holster when Mr. Orange is telling his anecdote about a drug deal. The cop on the far right of those pursuing Mr. Pink (Steve Buscemi), alos has a Colt Trooper MK III.
