| Error creating thumbnail: File missing Join our Discord! |
| If you have been locked out of your account you can request a password reset here. |
Talk:The Departed: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 33: | Line 33: | ||
I think some people preferred ''The Departed'' because, even though the two films have identical plots, the subtlety of the Chinese criminals in ''Infernal Affairs'' gives the film a slightly slower pace than the more flamboyant Irish criminals of ''The Departed'' gave to their respective movie. | I think some people preferred ''The Departed'' because, even though the two films have identical plots, the subtlety of the Chinese criminals in ''Infernal Affairs'' gives the film a slightly slower pace than the more flamboyant Irish criminals of ''The Departed'' gave to their respective movie. | ||
:I liked the subtleties. IA had better character development. Departed wrapped everything up a little too neatly. (And speaking of wrapping everything up a little too neatly, check out the Red Chinese ending, [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWT04Wkwtb4] Roughly translated, the police say they've uncovered that he's working for gangsters, and they take him away. And that's it.)--[[User:Funkychinaman|funkychinaman]] 03:31, 29 June 2010 (UTC) | :I liked the subtleties. IA had better character development. Departed wrapped everything up a little too neatly. (And speaking of wrapping everything up a little too neatly, check out the Red Chinese ending, [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWT04Wkwtb4] Roughly translated, the police say they've uncovered that he's working for gangsters, and they take him away. And that's it.)--[[User:Funkychinaman|funkychinaman]] 03:31, 29 June 2010 (UTC) | ||
::I'm not saying the subtleties are bad, however, there are some people who have shorter attention spans and prefer a quicker paced film. Also I did see the alternate ending and thought it was sort of a ''Deus ex Machina'' deal. I never knew that it was developed specifically for mainland China. Do all Honk Kong films have to have alternate "Communist Friendly" endings? Also, if the Mainland version used the alternate ending, what happened in ''[[Infernal Affairs 3]]'' when the truth came out? | |||
I'm Chinese, but I was born and raised in America, so I understand the cultural differences, but basically the plot is the exact same, the lines are almost the same. The girlfriend plot is the same. The old cop, etc. [[User:Excalibur01|Excalibur01]] 03:25, 29 June 2010 (UTC) | I'm Chinese, but I was born and raised in America, so I understand the cultural differences, but basically the plot is the exact same, the lines are almost the same. The girlfriend plot is the same. The old cop, etc. [[User:Excalibur01|Excalibur01]] 03:25, 29 June 2010 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 04:50, 29 June 2010
and
http://www.propstore.com/img/products/1455/Damon_SIG228_3.jpg
Damon's gun is a P228. Not a P226.
- I've been trying to figure this out myself. PropStore is selling the P228, but in the movie, Damon's gun clearly has the longer barrel and squared trigger guard of the P226. It's possible that armory which supplied the guns was short on 226s and had to use a 228 as a back-up weapon (all "hero" guns on movie sets have a back-up double). But as best I can tell, the only SIGs that appear on-screen in The Departed are 226s. -MT2008 13:09, 27 June 2010 (UTC)
The Image is called Damon_SIG228_3, nothing refering to THIS movie. Could this be a prop from the Bourne movies, didnt he use a 228 in that?
- If you go to the web site, Prop Store claims it was used by Damon in this movie, even though I'm not sure where (he only uses 226s on-screen, as far as I can tell). As for the Bourne movies, he uses SIG Pros in the first and last movies, and a P225 in the second. No P228s. -MT2008 17:57, 27 June 2010 (UTC)
- The description of the item does describe it as a P226 though. Maybe they're just using the wrong pictures. The pistol in the movie stills is clearly not the same gun as in the detail shots. --funkychinaman 18:20, 27 June 2010 (UTC)
Okay though, http://nranews.com/#/news/VideoModule/Handguns%20Used%20By%20All%20Star%20Cast%20Of%20Gangster%20Film.xml
- Oh come on, you'd think these guys of all people who be able to distinguish a P226 and a P228. And "silencer?" I KNOW this guy knows what's he's talking about too. He's been on "Tales of the Gun" many times. (And he's kind of let himself go.) --funkychinaman 20:09, 28 June 2010 (UTC)
Infernal Affairs rip off
I'm not saying the Departed is a bad movie and they even said they based the main villain boss off a real crook, but I seriously doubt these events were based on anything real. Everything about it is exactly the same as Infernal Affair, except the very last scene of the movie. If you saw the Departed first and then saw the Chinese movie, you'd think the Chinese ripped off a great American movie, but it's entirely the other way around. I'm not going to argue which is superior. They are both good movies since they both told the same story well, just that the Chinese did it first and made a sequel and a prequel out of it. I just want to put down my two cents about this fact. The people behind the movie Departed admitting a bit that their source was a legally acquired "remake" doesn't mean anything. There are remakes, reboots and then there's frame by frame thief. The Departed isn't a bad movie, but that's because it's the same thing of an already good Chinese movie. I mean they even did the same thing in both movies in hiring 2 very well known actors of their respective countries. If the audience sees 2 top actors in their movie, then it must win awards Excalibur01 15:29, 27 June 2010 (UTC)
- I completely agree that this is a virtual shot-for-shot remake of Infernal Affairs only grittyer, however, I seem to recall reading that Martin Scorsese bought the rights to remake IA as an American film. As long as he doesn't try to claim that this was his original idea, I don't see any problem with this being a remake. -Anonymous
- The fact that it was a remake was no secret, and it was even announced on Oscar night when it won best picture that it was a remake, although they messed up and referred to the original as a Japanese movie, instead of a Hong Kong movie. And for the record, I think the original IA was better. --funkychinaman 16:55, 27 June 2010 (UTC)
That is what hollywood does now...they cant make their own movie so they have gone out into the world and start to remake their hard earned movie. Look at "The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo". The movie was just put out in 2009 by europe and now hollywood wants to make it again with Daniel Craig and whatever hot american chick they can find. Hollywood wants to remake oldboy...which they should keep their greedy little hands off of because the original is mind blowing. Then lets not forget Death at a Funeral which was a funny movie all and all and it came out in 2007, then hollywood thought they would make a american black version not even two years later and didnt even have the respect for the British Version to replace the midget with another actor, they are that lame with non-originalism they didnt change one thing in the movie almost word for word scene for scene. Spades of Columbia
And it gets worse. I tried to show a buddy of mine who really liked Departed, showed him Infernal Affair and he liked the Departed more solely because he saw it first. If he saw Infernal Affairs first, then he'd like that and call the Departed a rip off. Excalibur01 02:31, 28 June 2010 (UTC)
I really liked both Infernal Affairs and The Departed. But when I watched The Departed, I pretty much laughed whenever someone drops an F bomb.
I think some people preferred The Departed because, even though the two films have identical plots, the subtlety of the Chinese criminals in Infernal Affairs gives the film a slightly slower pace than the more flamboyant Irish criminals of The Departed gave to their respective movie.
- I liked the subtleties. IA had better character development. Departed wrapped everything up a little too neatly. (And speaking of wrapping everything up a little too neatly, check out the Red Chinese ending, [1] Roughly translated, the police say they've uncovered that he's working for gangsters, and they take him away. And that's it.)--funkychinaman 03:31, 29 June 2010 (UTC)
- I'm not saying the subtleties are bad, however, there are some people who have shorter attention spans and prefer a quicker paced film. Also I did see the alternate ending and thought it was sort of a Deus ex Machina deal. I never knew that it was developed specifically for mainland China. Do all Honk Kong films have to have alternate "Communist Friendly" endings? Also, if the Mainland version used the alternate ending, what happened in Infernal Affairs 3 when the truth came out?
I'm Chinese, but I was born and raised in America, so I understand the cultural differences, but basically the plot is the exact same, the lines are almost the same. The girlfriend plot is the same. The old cop, etc. Excalibur01 03:25, 29 June 2010 (UTC)