| Error creating thumbnail: File missing Join our Discord! |
| If you have been locked out of your account you can request a password reset here. |
Talk:Magnum Force: Difference between revisions
StanTheMan (talk | contribs) |
StanTheMan (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 28: | Line 28: | ||
--[[User:Leon Okazaki|Leon Okazaki]] ([[User talk:Leon Okazaki|talk]]) 03:52, 11 July 2020 (EDT) | --[[User:Leon Okazaki|Leon Okazaki]] ([[User talk:Leon Okazaki|talk]]) 03:52, 11 July 2020 (EDT) | ||
: Are you fucking serious? Or is this some titchy trolling? Firearms safety is ALWAYS relevant whenever and wherever firearms are concerned, yes including - I would daresay especially - fictional media. Nevermind the site that chronicles firearms in said media. And one of the cardinal rules of handling firearms is you keep finger off and away from the trigger until the moment you're absolutely ready to fire. That is a rule that always applies but if ever there was a case it should apply more it would be especially on a weapon in a cocked state where it takes very little force on the trigger to shoot. <BR>If you watch the scene Harry is wielding his Model 29 in that fashion well before he actually fires, including a time when Callahan's partner is between him and the robber, blocking Callahan's line of fire. It's a ridiculous and unnecessary risk and a breach of basic gun safety that actual training will drill out of you and common sense should dissuade you from. <BR>As for your slight towards IMFDB editors - Which is strictly speaking pretty much everyone here - Quite a few of them are cops/ex-cops and soldiers/veterans that have the training (along with the sense) to know better than to violate basic gun safety and no | : Are you fucking serious? Or is this some titchy trolling? Firearms safety is ALWAYS relevant whenever and wherever firearms are concerned, yes including - I would daresay especially - fictional media. Nevermind the site that chronicles firearms in said media. And one of the cardinal rules of handling firearms is you keep finger off and away from the trigger until the moment you're absolutely ready to fire. That is a rule that always applies but if ever there was a case it should apply more it would be especially on a weapon in a cocked state where it takes very little force on the trigger to shoot. <BR>If you watch the scene Harry is wielding his Model 29 in that fashion well before he actually fires, including a time when Callahan's partner is between him and the robber, blocking Callahan's line of fire. It's a ridiculous and unnecessary risk and a breach of basic gun safety that actual training will drill out of you and common sense should dissuade you from. <BR>As for your slight towards IMFDB editors - Which is strictly speaking pretty much everyone here - Quite a few of them are cops/ex-cops and soldiers/veterans that have the training (along with the sense) to know better than to violate basic gun safety ever and no doubt have seem your so-called 'asinine commentary' and decided it was fine to stay due to its educational and informative value. You on the other hand, are as far as any of us know a red-paged nobody who thinks for whatever reason you can be a grand arbiter of what is or isn't 'asinine' to post on this wiki, and to make your grand statement you focus on an accurate, completely informational remark that has been posted on this page as long as I've been here, and I've been here a decade. With that being said, it's a good thing you didn't remove it, 'cause I'd put it right back. <BR>In closing, if you really think so negatively of us and have nothing to contribute but complaint of how we do things here - including reminders of safe firearms handling to anybody who peruses the site, I'd frankly feel no big loss if you up and left. Otherwise, maybe you at least might wanna build your user page and bother to give us an idea who the hell you actually are, that way we all can make an informed decision for ourselves on just how much consideration we should give your malformed criticisms, if any. [[User:StanTheMan|StanTheMan]] ([[User talk:StanTheMan|talk]]) 19:01, 11 July 2020 (EDT) | ||
Revision as of 23:22, 11 July 2020
That Model 29 has a 6 1/2" barrel. If you were to put the Model 29 with the 6.5" barrel and the other model with the 8 3/8" barrel you would see a noticable difference. I believe they might have used the longer barrel version for some shots for dramatic purposes, but mostly it's the 6.5" model. S&W stopped making the 6.5" and went to the 6" version in the late 70's. Which is what Eastwood uses in Sudden Impact and Dead Pool. Jcordell
AS for ammunition, Harry probably meant he's using a .44 light magnum, think of it like a .44 spl+P. "Light special load" may mean specially made and not a 44 special. There are some reduced recoil magnum rounds out there.
Yep one of the stranger things in the movie. It makes sense and as a shooter I understand the purpose, but it sort of does in the "Most powerful handgun in the world" line. Jcordell
On the DVD commentary John Milus the screenwriter notes that it shouldn't be "light special", but a lighter load. Like an 180 grain bullet compared to 200+ grain, I guess. --Predator20 17:33, 16 October 2009 (UTC)
(took the liberty of removing this commentary from the page. It belongs here on the discussion page. --Jcordell 20:08, 19 October 2009 (UTC)) Actually the director said in the commentary that he wrote the line wrong. They are actually light 44 magnum rounds, not .44 special rounds.--QBert 06:06,
GOOBER TOPIC: The fore-end of the "Winchester Model 70" rifle is closer to that of a Sako-Style Copy rifle.
Armory Room
In that third picture I see a Browning Hi-Power, a Reichsrevolver most likely the '79 but could be the '83, the barrel seems a bit short, an SAA possibly a copy, an M&P Smith, a .22 or .25 pocket pistol, the rest are obscured in the pic, but just a few frames later are visable. On the shelf I see a .32 or .38 topbreak, the second could be as well, but it's just a bit tough to tell. The second pic shows an AR-15 or a copy over Callahan's shoulder, note the sight. As for the third I can make out on the right what seems like the muzzle break of a Lee-Enfield Jungle Carbine, but sporterizing could explain that away. Black Irish Paddy (talk) 23:56, 9 October 2017 (EDT)
Hijacker's Model 10
That looks like a Smith & Wesson Victory Model to me. Note the finish. --Maxman (talk) 23:16, 11 July 2018 (EDT)
Justification for Harry's trigger finger
"Callahan aims his Model 29 through the two-way glass during the stakeout in the Cost Plus. Here Eastwood has a loaded gun cocked, with his finger on the trigger before he plans to fire it."
Dude, a robbery is taking place in the Cost Plus store, with a shotgun-wielding robber aiming at Callahan's partner posing as a cashier. Harry has every goddamn right to have his finger on the trigger with the hammer cocked, ready to blast the scumbag who might kill his partner at any time. Damn IMFDB editors, bringing up gun safety rules when it isn't relevant.
I first planned to edit out this comment, but I changed my mind and let it stay as it is, as a reminder of asinine gun commentary.
--Leon Okazaki (talk) 03:52, 11 July 2020 (EDT)
- Are you fucking serious? Or is this some titchy trolling? Firearms safety is ALWAYS relevant whenever and wherever firearms are concerned, yes including - I would daresay especially - fictional media. Nevermind the site that chronicles firearms in said media. And one of the cardinal rules of handling firearms is you keep finger off and away from the trigger until the moment you're absolutely ready to fire. That is a rule that always applies but if ever there was a case it should apply more it would be especially on a weapon in a cocked state where it takes very little force on the trigger to shoot.
If you watch the scene Harry is wielding his Model 29 in that fashion well before he actually fires, including a time when Callahan's partner is between him and the robber, blocking Callahan's line of fire. It's a ridiculous and unnecessary risk and a breach of basic gun safety that actual training will drill out of you and common sense should dissuade you from.
As for your slight towards IMFDB editors - Which is strictly speaking pretty much everyone here - Quite a few of them are cops/ex-cops and soldiers/veterans that have the training (along with the sense) to know better than to violate basic gun safety ever and no doubt have seem your so-called 'asinine commentary' and decided it was fine to stay due to its educational and informative value. You on the other hand, are as far as any of us know a red-paged nobody who thinks for whatever reason you can be a grand arbiter of what is or isn't 'asinine' to post on this wiki, and to make your grand statement you focus on an accurate, completely informational remark that has been posted on this page as long as I've been here, and I've been here a decade. With that being said, it's a good thing you didn't remove it, 'cause I'd put it right back.
In closing, if you really think so negatively of us and have nothing to contribute but complaint of how we do things here - including reminders of safe firearms handling to anybody who peruses the site, I'd frankly feel no big loss if you up and left. Otherwise, maybe you at least might wanna build your user page and bother to give us an idea who the hell you actually are, that way we all can make an informed decision for ourselves on just how much consideration we should give your malformed criticisms, if any. StanTheMan (talk) 19:01, 11 July 2020 (EDT)